Club PK
FC Bayern München vs Holstein Kiel
Pick below to start
Head-to-head player comparison · per-90 stats & DNA
Pick once · vote each round
Round 1 · Basics
Use the Pick buttons in the arena card to start.
Round 2 · Recent form
Use the Pick buttons in the arena card to start.
Round 3 · Per-90 comparison
Use the Pick buttons in the arena card to start.
Round 4 · DNA & style
Use the Pick buttons in the arena card to start.
Round 5 · Value fight
Use the Pick buttons in the arena card to start.
THE CALL: Alphonso Davies edges this comparison 55–45 on RT data — a tendency, not an absolute "better player" verdict. Market value: Alphonso Davies €50.0M vs John Tolkin €2.5M.
Davies has the stronger profile on minutes, rating, and market cues.
Davies carries sharper recent form — season and last-10 output tilt their way.
Davies has the sharper per-90 profile in their role; Tolkin still answers in theirs.
Tolkin edges the DNA round on style percentiles and archetype tags.
Pick
I'm backing Davies
Preview · read-only
Davies
Market value (€)
Tolkin
Davies
Season goals
Tolkin
Davies
Goals / 90
Tolkin
Davies looks stronger on value — fee, trend, or goal efficiency.
| Recent form |
| Clearances / 90 |
| 1.55 |
| 2.30 |
| Per-90 comparison | Passes / 90 | 61.95 | 38.61 |
| Per-90 comparison | Tackles won / 90 | 1.26 | — |
| Per-90 comparison | Interceptions / 90 | 0.52 | 2.17 |
| DNA & style | clearances · league rank | Beats 4% | Top 10% |
| DNA & style | Interceptions · league rank | Beats 8% | Top 46% |
| DNA & style | Tackles · league rank | Beats 41% | Top 21% |
Per-90 and seasonal stats from RT data. Use the interactive PK above for all five rounds.